How to Address a Defective Income Tax Return Notice

Filing an Income Tax Return (ITR) is an annual duty for eligible taxpayers in India. This isn’t just a formality—it’s a legal requirement ensuring accurate reporting of income and financial activities to the government. The Income Tax Department employs an automated system to meticulously scrutinize submitted returns, aiming for accuracy and efficiency. When discrepancies or errors are detected, a Notice under Section 139(9), known as a Defective Income Tax Return Notice, is issued. This article delves into the specifics of this notice, its purposes, and the steps to effectively respond.

Defective Income Tax Return Notice

Understanding the Notice Under Section 139(9) for Defective ITR

The Income Tax Department automatically issues a notification under Section 139(9) when errors or inconsistencies are found in a filed income tax return. This notice is generated immediately upon filing. It’s crucial to understand that this notification isn’t punitive; rather, it’s a mechanism to ensure the taxpayer’s information is accurate and aligns with data from other sources.

Defective Income Tax Return Notice

Common Causes for Issuing Income Tax Notice U/S 139(9) for Defective Return

The primary aim of this notice is to reconcile the reported income in the ITR with information from other sources. Here are typical reasons for its issuance:

  • Discrepancies in Reported Income: The system compares the income reported in the ITR with data from the AIS (Annual Information Statement), TIS (Tax Information Network), and Form 26AS. Discrepancies trigger the notice.
  • Incomplete TDS Credits and Unreported Income: If a taxpayer omits income related to TDS or claims TDS credit while reporting lower income than reflected in Form 26AS, a notice will be issued.
  • Tax Liability with Zero Income: The Income Tax Department may issue a notice if a taxpayer declares “nil” income across all categories while still computing and paying tax.
  • Missing Mandatory Fields: ITR forms have specific required fields. If these fields are incomplete or incorrect, the return is considered defective.
  • Ignoring Financial Statements: Taxpayers with income under “Profits and Gains of Business or Profession” must submit a Balance Sheet and Profit and Loss Account. Failure to comply can result in a notice.
  • Name Mismatch: If the taxpayer’s name in the ITR does not match the PAN database, the Income Tax Department may issue a notice.
  • Incorrect Reporting Under Section 194N: Taxpayers must ensure accurate reporting of any TDS claimed under Section 194N (cash withdrawal). Discrepancies can lead to a notice.

Defective Income Tax Return Notice

Consult CA Arun Tiwari for more information at 📞 8080088288 or cs@aktassociates.com

Steps to Respond to a Defective ITR Notice Under Section 139(9)

Receiving a defective income tax return notice can be stressful, but addressing it promptly and accurately can ease the process. Here’s how you can revise a defective notice and respond effectively:

1. Understand the Discrepancy

First, thoroughly read the notice to understand the specific issue flagged by the Income Tax Department. The notice will typically outline the discrepancy or error found in your ITR.

2. Collect Necessary Documents

Gather all relevant documents and information, such as your Form 16, Form 26AS, bank statements, and any other supporting documents related to the discrepancy. This will help you accurately correct the error or provide the necessary explanations.

Defective Income Tax Return Notice

3. Log into Your Income Tax Account

Access your account on the Income Tax Department’s e-filing portal. Navigate to the ‘e-Proceedings’ or ‘My Pending Actions’ section to find the defective return notice.

4. Select the Correct Option

Depending on the nature of the notice, you have a few options:

  • Filing ITR Under Section 139(9): You can file a return with the correct information even if the deadline for a revised ITR has passed.
  • Correcting Discrepancies: If the notice highlights genuine errors or omissions, submit an amended return with updated information, provided the deadline for the assessment year hasn’t passed.
  • Responding Online: If you believe the notice is incorrect, you can respond online via your income tax portal account, providing clarifications and supporting documents.

5. Submit the Response

Once you’ve made the necessary corrections or prepared your response, submit it through the portal. Complete all required fields and double-check the information before submission to avoid further errors.

6. Follow Up

After submission, monitor your income tax account for any further notices or updates from the Income Tax Department. They may request additional information or provide confirmation that the issue has been resolved.

Conclusion

Addressing a defective income tax return notice under Section 139(9) may seem daunting, but understanding the process and responding promptly can help resolve the issue efficiently. Always ensure that your ITR is accurate and complete to avoid such notices in the future. If you have any questions or need further assistance, feel free to leave a comment below!

Leave a Comment